As reputable tire brands, Toyo and Cooper stand out, with their strengths and characteristics in the market.
So which is better for your tire needs, Toyo or Cooper? Distinguishing between Toyo and Cooper tires often boils down to two key differences – performance focus and price range.
Also, Toyo tires usually produce less noise.
Meanwhile, Cooper tires strike a balance between performance and affordability, catering to a wider range of drivers seeking dependable tires without breaking the bank.
In this article, I’m diving into the key differences between two tire giants. Read carefully to make an informed decision. You can check Name Brand vs Off Brand Tires comparison.
Head-to-head Comparison of Toyo vs Cooper Tires
Explore the comprehensive head-to-head comparison of Toyo and Cooper tires in this detailed table. Both tires have some similar features. There are also some differences.
| Aspects | Toyo Tires | Cooper tires |
| Diameter | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Tread width | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Tire type | All-season, summer, performance, off-road, etc. | All-season, touring, performance, on-road, etc. |
| Load Rating | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Compatible for | Cars, trucks, SUVs, performance vehicles, etc. | Cars, light trucks, SUVs, off-road vehicles, etc. |
| Aspect ratio | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Internal construction | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Speed rating | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Rim diameter | Varies by tire model and size. | Varies by tire model and size. |
| Low rolling resistance (Yes/No) | Feature low rolling resistance technology. | Very good on rolling resistance |
| Price | Higher in price compared to Cooper tires | Budget-friendly |
Let’s do some core analysis –
Performance
Toyo and Cooper offer tires designed for different performance needs, including all-season, touring, and off-road.
Toyo is often praised for its high-performance tires, especially in the sports car and enthusiast market.
For example, Toyo Proxes Sport A/S has a very good reputation regarding handling. This is an Ultra-high performing tire from Toyo.
Cooper also offers a range of performance tires, focusing on durability and handling. For example, Cooper Zeon RS3-G1 is well known for dry road performance.
Technology
Both companies invest in tire technology.
Toyo Proxes Comfort features NanoEnergy and T-Mode technologies for improved fuel efficiency and comfort.
Cooper Discoverer EnduraMax utilizes Wear Square technology to monitor tread wear and improve durability.
Durability
Toyo tires are known for their robust construction and longevity, particularly in their all-terrain and off-road tire lines.
Features like reinforced sidewalls and advanced tread compounds contribute to their durability, making them well-suited for challenging driving conditions.
Cooper tires, on the other hand, are often praised for their ruggedness and resilience, especially in their off-road and all-terrain tire offerings.
They’re engineered to withstand tough terrains and heavy loads, making them popular choices for trucks and SUVs used in demanding environments.
Tread design
Toyo and Cooper often have distinct tread designs tailored to different driving conditions.
Toyo may focus more on advanced tread patterns for enhanced traction and handling, particularly in wet or dry conditions.
Cooper, on the other hand, might emphasize tread designs optimized for all-terrain or off-road performance, with features like aggressive tread blocks for better grip on rugged surfaces.
Tread Depth
Toyo tires typically offer tread depths that are optimized for specific driving conditions.
Their high-performance tires may have shallower tread depths to enhance traction and handling on dry roads.
But, their all-terrain tires may have deeper tread depths for improved off-road performance. For example, Toyo Open Country A/T III (265/70R17) has a 13.3” tread depth.
Cooper tires also vary in tread depth based on the tire model and intended use. Their all-season and touring tires might have moderate tread depths for balanced performance in various conditions.
But their off-road and all-terrain tires may feature deeper tread depths to provide better grip on rugged terrain.
For example, Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S (265/70R17) has a 14” tread depth.
Noise levels
Tire noise can affect driving comfort, especially on long trips. And both of these tire brands perform well in terms of noise reduction.
Toyo tires are known for their quiet and comfortable ride, achieved through advanced noise reduction technologies.
Cooper tires also prioritize reducing road noise, often incorporating features like noise-canceling tread designs or optimized tread pitch to minimize cabin noise.
Load Index
Toyo and Cooper tires adhere to industry standards for load index ratings, ensuring that their tires can safely carry the specified load under normal operating conditions.
For example, the Toyo Open Country A/T III tire might have a load index from 102 to 116 or more.
In the load index system, 116 corresponds to a maximum load-carrying capacity of 2,756 pounds per tire. This indicates that each tire can safely support a load of up to 2,756 pounds when properly inflated.
Similarly, the Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S tire might have a load index of 108.
In the load index system, 108 corresponds to a maximum load-carrying capacity of 2,256 pounds per tire.
This means that each tire can safely support a load of up to 2,256 pounds when inflated to the recommended air pressure.
Internal Construction
Toyo tires often incorporate advanced materials like high-tensile steel belts and specialized rubber compounds in their internal construction.
For example, the Toyo Open Country A/T III features a robust carcass construction with reinforced sidewalls. It uses a sustainable 2-ply polyester case.
Cooper tires typically feature high-strength steel belts and durable polyester or nylon cord plies in their internal construction.
The Cooper Discoverer STT Pro utilizes Armor-Tek3 construction with a high-strength tread compound for rugged off-road performance and durability.
Speed Rating
Toyo and Cooper both brands offer a variety of speed ratings across their tire lineup, indicating the maximum speed capability of the tires.
Toyo offers tires with a range of speed ratings, including popular ratings like S (up to 112 mph), T (up to 118 mph), H (up to 130 mph), V (up to 149 mph), and W (up to 168 mph).
There is a Speed Rating W on the Toyo Proxes 4 Plus (up to 168 mph).
Similarly, Cooper offers tires with various speed ratings, including common ratings like S, T, H, V, and W.
The specific speed ratings available can vary by tire model and size. Cooper CS5 Ultra Touring comes with Speed Rating H (up to 130 mph).
Mileage
Mileage varies depending on the specific tire model and driving conditions. They offer mileage warranties for certain tire lines.
Toyo AT3 is backed by a 65k-mile warranty. But the Cooper RS-3G1 comes with a 55k-mile warranty.
Price
Toyo tires generally come at a slightly higher price point compared to Cooper tires.
For example, a Toyo Open Country A/T III in size 265/70R17 might cost around $293 per tire.
In the meantime, a Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S in the same size could be priced at around $182 per tire.
However, actual prices can vary based on factors such as tire size, model, retailer, and promotions.
Cooper discoverer at3 vs Toyo open country AT3
These tires share similar all terrain capabilities although with different strengths and weaknesses as the comparison between Cooper Rugged Trek vs Toyo Open Country AT3. The Cooper Rugged Trek is suitable for drivers who love to get off highway and has an aggressive tread pattern with a durable construction meant to keep up in even the roughest terrain.
Toyo Open Country tires aim for a balanced performance, including excellent in and off the road operations with reduced noise level and fuel consumption (but not great over dry tarmac). Ultimately, which one of the two you decide to go with depends on if they want top performance off-road or an option that has all season/road friendly qualities.
Final Recommendations
After weighing the strengths and characteristics of Toyo and Cooper tires, it’s time to crown a champion.
While both brands offer impressive options suited to various driving needs, one emerges as the clear winner for overall performance, durability, and value.
Based on the analysis, I think, Toyo tires stand out as the top choice for drivers seeking a winning combination of high performance and cutting-edge technology.
However, it depends on your needs. So, after considering your purposes, choose a tire.
Must Check Out others Brand Name Tires Comparison.